Laerise:
With due respect, the anti-CCP echo chamber is no more reliable than the pro-PC, pro-Xbox, or pro-PS3 partisans that rove the web in slavering packs. Human beings are a clannish lot by nature, and permanently beset by confirmation bias, among other entertaining psychological phenomena.
This icon, right here?

Yeah, that one. It's become the avatar of fundamental attribution error as applied by fans to CCP. "CCP has goofed in the past. Therefore they are goofy, and can be depended on to goof."
It's a bit of non-logic I ran out of patience with ages ago.
DUST is unfinished. I'm actually kind of appalled that anybody is writing reviews of a beta product; it's like reviewing a novel before it gets looked at by an editor. If I had to write a review of it in its beta state, I'd call it "intriguing, but worrying, but intriguing" and leave it at that. I might consider adding that it's not as bad as I was afraid it would be, but there's still plenty of room for things to get worse, so that, too, seems premature.
It's a freaking beta-- a freaking beta you're not even IN. Between the early state of affairs and your imperfect information, a little tempering of the predictions of doom is called for.