Well this thread is properly aged...
Favorite EvE RP moment is after my ship was shot down by Odeyla (or however you spell it, can't be arsed to look it up)
She was on that whole "I hate PIE and those who follow the Theology counsel and false empress" arc thing. In all honesty I had little idea what was going on. I haven't been with PIE for long and I was only getting my feet wet in EvE RP so I never kept up with what was going on with that story before this incident.
Well, jumping to the meat of this story I logged in and figured I would get some solo PvP in and headed in a random direction into the warzone, sitting on a button here or there, but never staying for long in any one system. That is until one system I saw on D dcan an astero and a Tristan on the nearby small plex. There were two other people in local. A Gallente FW pilot and Odeyla.
So of course I warp strait to the plex to see if I can either tip the scales or whore on a KM just like Aldy taught me to do in such a situation
. Come to find out The Astero was Odeyla and the Tristan buggered out as soon as I landed. I decided to stay in the plex and tick it down because the pilot that was scarred off I knew had friends and could be back with them, making a fun fight if Odeyla stayed.
What happened next surprised the hell out of me. Odeyla locked me up after exactly one minute of pushing the button. The Astero locked me up, nueted me out, and ripped my ship asunder. I still managed to get my pod out, and on the way out of system Odelya says "send my regards to admiral Lokri"
Needless to say I was a bit bummed in and out of character. I was shot down by a fellow militiaman when it's all said and done. But when I look back on it I see it as a fun experience that I wish I could have taken better advantage of. Even though I had very little part in that arc it still felt good to be a part of a story that involved many people and that is why it is my favorite RP moment in EvE.
Not super exciting, complicated, or grand but it is what it is.