In my opinion the only reason that Nation can approach a post-scarcity living standard for it's citizens is because most of its workers ARE drones, literally.
The Culture gets away with having a consumerist post-scarcity culture by having matter and energy be effectively equivalent and by having access to limitless energy though AM and 'hypersphere' engineering.
Meanwhile, back in Eve, we're still mining Asteroids for ore and the most new-fangled form of energy generation is harnessing the gravitic grid by creating pocket-singularities. (seriously, doesn't that creep anyone else out?) But only one of the Factions uses that - the others use Fusion or even, horror of horrors, Fission powerplants.
Absolutely see your point(s), Pieter. Re: Nation/literal drones - yes and ... no.
I'm not sure if it's actually echoed anywhere in PF but I've always liked the Nation-loyalist's approach that the Sansha 'mind control' implants are a lot more subtle than a simple plug-n-play automated workforce . There's a couple of pieces in the fiction board on these forums that sum up what those implants are IMO - and it's far more creepy than just 'drones'.
Also, TCMCs
are a part of PF which opens up a wider view of how New Eden humanity might function differently to 21st century us.
Anyway, back on topic ...
I find it more gritty with the margin. That can be reduced to 1 or 2% because of AI and automation coupled with prediction programs, but you will hardly control demographics that precisely in Eve I believe.
It's funnier to have people failing in the cracks imo.
I guess my point was that because of these technologies, the concept of a section of civilisation
approaching a society of the sort Elusenia proposes to be certainly isn't far-fetched enough to interfere with immersion. My other point was not to get hung up on numbers that are based on 21st century figures because in terms of our ability to speculate based on current tech/systems we are to New Eden what cavemen trying to figure out the future uses of fire would be to us.
Ultimately it doesn't matter whether it's 95%, 98%, 99.9% or somewhere in between - we're not trying to create SimCity: New Eden, we're just trying to create a backdrop that suspends disbelief enough to set our RP against. And, as you said, have fun doing so.
On to the specifics, can we really assume that Elusenia is known across the entire cluster by name, without needing to specify Seriphyn or Destiny Foundation? Can we assume that a high profile celebrity living in the heart of Caille would know what Elusenia is? Would the average Federation citizen know?
Well, Seriphyn's a war hero and might be expected to have a fairly high profile I suppose. I think your point's a valid one though - guess it depends on how good their marketing and human resources/recruitment departments are