What follows are my opinion in general, not directed at anyone in particular.
Whenever I've the funds, I'll pre-order this to get the days ahead (hogging names, mostly) and much like SW:TOR I'll give this a fair trial period of a month at the very least.
The game-mechanics interests me immensely, from the fact area-effect attacks, positioning, agility and movement play major parts in PVP, archers and mages needs to aim, to possibly friendly-fire incidents... to the fact people can DECLARE themselves outlaws, thus earning the right to attacks anyone level 11 (or whatever it ends up being in-release) to 60 and being attacked by anything with a pulse as a response. Instant -10 and free aggro for everyone! Outlawed/Vigilante guilds in conflict and the dynamics between these will likely be pure, distilled enjoyment. Or an gigantic collection of fail and grief-festing, depending. The political scene looks promising as well, but can risk falling into the same line of shit as Linage II.
The negatives seen so far are purely aesthetics. I FUCKING
HATE PORN-ARMOR. And FUCKING
PIMPS. Humans, Castanic and High elves are the most glaring examples. Humans, whose males look like smooth pretty boys and the females scantly-clad whores, VS the Uber-pimps and super-whores, (Castanic) and High Elves just... I'm not sure if
EMO BITCHES will ever cover it.
Would it have killed them to design functional armor? It certainly WILL kill them not to have done that. Female Human Lancers, for example - supposedly tanky heavy armor users, and one of the example's of high-level gear includes a suit of heavy armor. Looks good, overall... if not for that hole IN.THE.CHEST. to make an opening to expose some tits. Male Castonic's in anything from cloth to leather to full-plate incorporating feline spots in the clothes and fur to look like the MOSTHANDSOMEPUSHERSEVER. And the faces... sure, we have magic. Scars and injury can be removed with ease, allowing for all the pretty-boy/girl melee-specialists you ever want.
But it all looks so pretty. So, very, very, pretty.
The races I can forgive though are the loli-like Elin, the Baraka and the Draconic-like Aman. Can't for the life of me take the Popori seriously. Honestly, a griefer's mental image of a carebear is likely to be one of these guys...
Elin in particular, from the descriptions and their appearance, are down-right play-worthy - their appearance alone will make opponents underestimate them, sub-consciously and actually, because they will think in the lines of this;
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
Innocent, frail, non-combatant.
Back-story however claims something along these lines...
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
Dark, brooding, willing, able and capable... appearances, deceptive, etc. etc. The Aman are pretty nice too, and are among the most functional in clothing-style, or so it would seem. They remind me a little about these;
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
I'm likely going to focus my toons into these two races.
As for the theft accusations, far as I can see it's a separate issue that has been resolved allready - the guilty parties have been punished and the sue towards the company has not gone as NCSoft wished. Or did I miss something? Have hardly slept in two days here, so I'll admit I might miss something.