Ok, so i'm kind of in a dilemna right now...
I inherited from a hotas warthog a while back, which works awesomely and is probably the best joystick ever (bare the weird buttons but well),
Noice!
but I got no throttle addon, and no pedal rudder either.
Put the stick between your legs (giggity) and use a keyboard for your left hand. Fingers at WSAD. Map yaw to X (as its way more important then rolling in space) and use the already mapped Q and E keys for roll.
What I am wondering is that this stick is really designed for flight hardcore sims and my main issue with it is that it doesn't have a z roll axis, which is a real hindrance and asks for a rudder. My other concern is if the throttle is really ergonomic and suited to the game or not.
Yes.
Absolutely yes.
I have an X55 (don't judge, it was super insanely cheap) and the throttle is a Godsend. Being able to dynamicly adjust speed and heading is brilliant. If a hostile is on my tail, I can decouple, fly around an asteroid while pointing the nose of my ship at my target. When he comes around the asteroid, he'll get a face full of laser and rocket fire. With practice, I could do that with a keyboard, but it doesn't have the same... Feel. HOTAS allows for a much more immersive experence, IMHO.
So, should I also get a throttle (maybe another brand if this one is not suited ?), and a rudder and roll with that ? Sounds heavily intensive and costly.
Should you? First pledge. If you like the game, then slowly invest in a throttle... then rudder pedals. (Birfday is coming up real soon, I'ma gonna treat myself to some pedals)
Or should I sell/get rid of the warthog and get another stick ? Either a hotas with z axis directly in the stick like a Saitek, or a non hotas stick like the T-16000 ?
As previously stated, I have an x55. If you want a slightly shittier experience, then get what I have. Buttons randomly press, there is a large deadzone that needs to be fixed in the software, and customer service is easily the worst I've ever experienced. If this weren't a Christmas present, I'd take it back and get a warthog.
Is it better to go for a hotas since it may provide a lot of supplemental buttons and stuff and you do not have to reach for your keyboard ?
Yes..?
I've got a nice setup, but I'm in the process of building a sort of cockpit. I'm going to have a U-shaped tray that goes over my lap, divided into five positions. The far left will house my rudder, the middle will have my joystick, and the far right will have the mouse. Between the joystick, mouse, and throttle will be one of these.
http://www.thehumansolution.com/kinesis-freestyle.html?gdftrk=gdfV2929_a_7c132_a_7c5187_a_7cKIN700&gclid=CL-S_4eegsQCFZLm7AodYwkAjwWhen they start to support it, I'm going to pick up VR of some sort... After a month or two, y'all will see me on the news... Gamer dies in home made simulator from malnutrition.