I have difficulties to understand all the fuss here. What Kaleigh said...
I also have difficulties to understand what makes the author of this article feel that way. Everyone knows how sharp I am when it comes to shitty stories and the rule of testosterone drive plots in video games (hell, I am even one of the few people i know that spit on Mass Effect ludicrous cheesy stories ala hollywood with heroes overbuffed by testosterone, while still praising its universe though). Well I did not find the story of SC2 bad. I almost found it quite decent, and very entertaining, without the usual clichés. Of course then, you can always find some clumsy things here and there but overall I found it very well done, nothing overdone or overused, or at least not a lot. The only thing that I did not really like was all that stuff around the XelNaga that was definitly "too much", eventually diverts us from the main plot to go to the new big threat of doom coming out like a deus ex machina to kill them all.
But reading this article, I for one just think that the author must simply be a queen of blades fanboy (considering how he always speaks of her) that did not like at all to see his actual sexual object denatured and "re feminized". I do not have the feeling to read real points in his article but more grief after grief because he got somehow butthurt by the outcome of the scenario.